Ameican Idol----A tough cut tonite.

• HitsRus

  

  The remaining six sang a duet and a solo song....Carole King week....and the performances were good.
  
  James Durbin and Jacob Lusk duet....A
  Jacob Solo...B+
  James Solo...A
  
  Haley and Casey came out of the closet on their duo....A
  Haley solo ...A-
  Casey solo...A-
  
  The country kids paired for a duet.....B+...but the strength of the performance came from Lauren.
  Lauren solo...B
  Scotty solo B+
  
  
  I'd be sending Lauren home tonite, but I feel it'll Jacob.
  
  Tough cuts from now on.
• THE4RINGZ

  

  I was only able to see performances from Scotty on. I thought James kicked ass again. And how many times do we have to watch that Casey jackass and his 1940's lounge act? I leave the room when that ass clown comes on stage.
  
  All that being said, I hope Jacob goes home tonight.
• Manhattan Buckeye

  THE4RINGZ;752645 wrote:I was only able to see performances from Scotty on. I thought James kicked ass again. And how many times do we have to watch that Casey jackass and his 1940's lounge act? I leave the room when that ass clown comes on stage.
  
  All that being said, I hope Jacob goes home tonight.

  Agreed, the concept of tough cut and Casey is beyond me. He blows, he should never have been saved by the judges. He simply is a lounge act (per THE4RINGZ).
• 1_beast

  

  Casey = Lounge act, Jacob = Church Choir
  
  James = winner winner chicken dinner!
• Belly35

  

  Bottom Three:
  
  Casey
  Jacob
  Bubble: Laura or Scotty
  
  Send Casey home how many times do we have to hear "grunting" in a song.... Casey "grunting" is like Taylor Hicks "whoo" it get old fast….
• brutus161

  

  I also hated Casey last night. Halfway through the song, I quit paying attention.
• se-alum

  

  Regardless of what happens, I think Scott and Lauren are the only ones we hear anything from after this show is over.
• ernest_t_bass

  

  Jacob tonight
  Haley next week
  Lauren after that
  
  My predictions.
• ernest_t_bass

  

  se-alum;752813 wrote:Regardless of what happens, I think Scott and Lauren are the only ones we hear anything from after this show is over.

  
  Disagree. James Durbin will be with a group.
• vball10set

  if anyone but Jacob goes home, I'll be disappointed
• GoPens

  

  Casey is entering Taylor Hicks territory. I just don't get how the hell he's lasted this long--plus he's annoying as hell.
  
  My early picks were Pia and James. If he doesn't win it now, America has no sense for talent. Scotty will have a very successful country career.
• ernest_t_bass

  

  GoPens;753062 wrote:America has no sense for talent.

  
  An incredible understatement. As much as I hated Adam Lambert, tell me how he lost that competition... Homophobes.
• Little Danny

  

  I don't know what pisses me off more, the fact Casey is still on the show or the fact he is banging Haley, despite looking like Seth Rogan's annoying little brother.
  
  In all seriousness, he needs to go. His schtick is lame and as Simon used to always say, the show is to find that person we would hear on the radio one day. I can't picture listening to Casey on the radio for more than five seconds before changing the station.... The Taylor Hicks analogy is perfect.
  
  Btw, my favorite part of last night was looking at J-Lo legs during James/Jacob's duet. The duet, however, sucked.
• bigdaddy2003

  

  vball10set;752998 wrote:if anyone but Jacob goes home, I'll be disappointed

  
  This.
• Tiger2003

  

  Jacob, Casey and Scotty bottom 3....
• Tiger2003

  

  Bye Bye Casey!!!!!
  
  
  Really liked the kid.....Jacob needs to fucking go.....
• 1_beast

  

  I was waiting on Casey to drop a deuce on stage as much grunting he was doing....good riddance!!!! Next to go.....Jacob.
• THE4RINGZ

  

  Glad that clown is going home. I had hoped it was either him or Jacob. I can't stand him either.
• tuskytuffguy

  As much as Jacob is a drama queen and gets on my nerves, I want Scott to go before him. Haley too. Jacob for 3rd, and James and Lauren in the final with James running away with the title.
• bigdaddy2003

  

  I will be happy if Jacob is next. I kind of liked Casey but his "lounge act" was getting kind of old.
• Timber

  One gets the feeling that you bastards do not like lounge acts I always liked Bill Murray on SNL... the GOAT lounge act!
• Manhattan Buckeye

  "Star Wars, if they should bar wars, please let these star wars, staaaayyyyyyyy"
• HitsRus

  

  I cannot see what's so great about Lauren Alaina. She's okay but.....c'mon...she brings very little to the stage. She certainly doesn't have a better voice than Pia Toscano, and her arrangments aren't very interesting. Even if you didn't like Casey's 'growling' at least he put on a show. Why is Lauren still here?
  
  Jacob needs a home run if he's to stay in past this week. Scotty is slumping badly just when he needs to kick it up a notch. Haley is rallying...getting better every week. James has a lock on a finals spot.
• Little Danny

  

  HitsRus;753957 wrote:I cannot see what's so great about Lauren Alaina. She's okay but.....c'mon...she brings very little to the stage. She certainly doesn't have a better voice than Pia Toscano, and her arrangments aren't very interesting. Even if you didn't like Casey's 'growling' at least he put on a show. Why is Lauren still here?
  
  Jacob needs a home run if he's to stay in past this week. Scotty is slumping badly just when he needs to kick it up a notch. Haley is rallying...getting better every week. James has a lock on a finals spot.

  
  She's a country girl--- in fact she is a blonde haired, blue eyed country girl. Middle America loves that. Ditto with Scotty being a country boy. They will continue to stay. After one gets voted off the other will be in the final against James due to all of the votes they pick up from the other.