American Idol 4/6 and elimination 4/7

• HitsRus

  

  Really tough cut. Very few weak spots.
  
  Jacob Lusk A-
  Haley... B+
  Casey ...B+
  Lauren ...B
  Scotty ...A
  Pia ...B
  James Durbin..B
  Stephano...c+
  Paul...C+
  
  
  
  I'm not sure what the judges actually liked about Paul's or Stephano's performances....but I think one of them is going home tomorrow. Overall, a very good nite.
• THE4RINGZ

  

  My bottom three:
  
  Jacob
  Casey
  Stefano
  
  I see Stefano going home.
• GoPens

  

  My bottom three:
  
  Stefano
  Paul
  Lauren
  
  With Stefano going home.
  
  This year should go down to Pia and James Durbin as your final 2.
• THE4RINGZ

  

  I was a little upset that some people chose to sing Motown songs. I thought Paul turned in a nice performance tonight. Casey took a rock song and turned it into a lounge act. Pia seemed uninspired.
• dave

  the real question, how did Pia look?
• Tiger2003

  

  dave;735193 wrote:the real question, how did Pia look?

  
  Are you really asking that question?
• Little Danny

  

  THE4RINGZ;735175 wrote:I was a little upset that some people chose to sing Motown songs. I thought Paul turned in a nice performance tonight. Casey took a rock song and turned it into a lounge act. Pia seemed uninspired.

  
  The theme was the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Since the Hall of Fame has admitted those singers, they are technically correct.
  
  I was really disappointed in James Durbin. Yeah, I get the whole "growing as an artist" thing, but I think he did himself a disservice by slowing it down with the George Harrison tune. I think America wanted to see him take the house down last night.
  
  I am missing Simon more and more each week. Every judge thought each contestant was absolutely wonderful (or in the word's of Steven "Just Beautiful"). The closest we got to a criticism was when Randy said Stefano started out a little "shaky".
  
  Stefano, Paul and Haley are your bottom three. Despite the fact Stefano was crooning to J-Lo with "When a man loves a woman" (and she was absolutely gushing after his performance last night by the way ), he goes home this week.
• Belly35

  

  My bottom three
  
  Casey .. sorry he lost it .. not impressed anymore.. every song he has to grinded out some words little old now
  Stefano .... I think people just do not like him .. that Frank Sinatra vib
  Paul .... sorry never like him ...I can only live my life with one Rod Steward ... what the judges see in this guy is beyond me
  
  
  Lauren ... (on the bubble) she did a great job but I think people are liking Haily more now so some of those vote will be for Haily
• HitsRus

  

  My botom three prediction
  
  Paul, Stephano and Haley
  
  
  Stephano goes home and JLo's heart is broken.
• Ankle Breaker

  

  Pia goes home. You've got to be kidding.
• royal_k

  

  Pia going home was a big mistake. Never saw that coming....
• Ironman92

  

  Pia finishing 8th is idiotic.
• Manhattan Buckeye

  What is pathetic is that the judge's save was wasted on that no talent assclown Casey. He's a poor version of Taylor Hicks. Pia/James are by far the most talented (I understand the appeal of Scott), at any rate Pia/James/Scott will all have careers in the music industry. Jacob might as well. The rest, likely not.
• Lovejoy1984

  

  Pia should've lasted longer but she was boring so I can understand why people didn't vote for her.
  
  Amazing singer and very pretty, but like I said pretty boring.
  
  I still would've sent Jacob, Haley, and Paul home before her though.
• GoPens

  

  Manhattan Buckeye;735910 wrote:What is pathetic is that the judge's save was wasted on that no talent assclown Casey. He's a poor version of Taylor Hicks. Pia/James are by far the most talented (I understand the appeal of Scott), at any rate Pia/James/Scott will all have careers in the music industry. Jacob might as well. The rest, likely not.

  
  +1. I bet the judges kept saying "Oh shit, we wasted our save" when they saw the bottom 3.
  
  Some label will sign Pia and she'll do alright, but this is ridiculous that she's gone so soon.
  
  I thought it was comical that Seacrest was almost begging people to keep watching the show at the end now that one of the 2 best singers just got eliminated.
• tuskytuffguy

  Good voice, hot girl, but plain and simple, the most boring of the group. It doesn't surprise me a bit.
• THE4RINGZ

  

  She was all hat and no cattle.
  
  If you want to hear Pia sing, go big a Celine Dion CD.
• HitsRus

  

  ^^^^agree with that. Great voice...but. The whole thing is about people being motivated enough to vote for you and /or buy your records or act.
  
  But I also think that she was 'offed' much too soon. ...she was top 5 al least, and the best vocalist of the bunch. I had to laugh a bit at least.... Randy Jackson was caught on camera saying "Fuck no!"...censors caught it just at the 'no' part....LOL.
• Manhattan Buckeye

  If Pia is a wannabe Celine Dion, what is Casey? I'll tell you who he is, he's the loser at every college campus that tries to sing at happy hour that no one pays attention to. The guy sucks. His rendition of "Smells Like Teen Spirit" may have been the worst thing I've seen on television (slight hyperbole). At least Pia has talent. Why did the judges save him again?
• Belly35

  

  Pia has a career now, she will be sing, marketing and movies .... she was one of my top four
  Casey, Paul, Stephano should be gone before Pia.
• GoPens

  

  It is almost a crime that she's gone while no talent hacks like Stephano and Casey are still in this.
  
  I'll probably be wrong again (because who knows how the teeny-boppers who vote on this show will vote) but I think things got a whole lot easier for James Durbin to win this, with Jacob Lusk the dark horse.
• bogey

  Yea, Pia shouldn't have gone home yet. But after the original shock of hearing her name as the one eliminated, most people will not be as surprised when looking back at her performances. I think the biggest thing she lacked was that ability to connect to the audience. I kept waiting for her to lose the high heeled shoes and get some movement in her act and engage with the crowd. Even when she was moving around the stage she didn't seem to have the presence or connection to people. While some of the others left on the show are less talented singers, their ability to perform and connect to people is what keeps them around. Stefano drives me nuts because I just think he looks to fake, and I too was wondering what the judges thought of using their save so early on Casey.
  One other thing that may have helped Pia would be the judges actually judging now and giving America some of their actual "expert" opinion on these guys.....I mean come on, I'm tired of Steven saying "you nailed it", Jennifer saying "I have goose pimples", and Randy raving "that's how you do it." This is a very well rounded group with different qualities and I thought the judges did a good job of building them up early on, but now they need to start giving brutal honesty!
• se-alum

  

  Pia was an older version of Thia, but nobody wanted to admit it because of how hot she is. I'm not sold on the fact that she'll ever be relevant in mainstream music.
• vball10set

  GoPens;736029 wrote:It is almost a crime that she's gone while no talent hacks like Stephano and Casey are still in this.

  
  this, and I'd put that MJ wannabe, Jacob, in this category as well
• Tiernan

  Pia's rack & tush will get her signed by some label. The big gay crybaby has got to go just for the "America can't look at itself in the mirror" remark. Plus I want to see all Auhnties and G-mas absolutely crap a brick when he finally gets booted.