American Idol...3/9-3/10 elimination

• HitsRus

  

  Last nite's top performers IMO
  
  Casey ----A
  Pia---A
  James Durbin....B+
  
  
  
  On the bubble tonite
  
  Karen Rodriguez----C-
  Naima---C
  Mia....C
  Lauren Alaina...-C+
  AShton....C+
  
  Not a really good nite for the girls.
  Stephano wasn't too bad, and he has an angel in JLo watching over him. Specuation...she reminds him of hubby Marc Anthony.
• se-alum

  

  How many people get eliminated tonite??
• THE4RINGZ

  

  I see Ashton, Karen, and Paul all packing their bags tonight. Thing is I really liked Ashton early on but as of late she has completly fizzled out.
• rydawg5

  the country singer annoys the crap out me. he smirks or something the whole time and he isnteven that good. he needs to go or the selena wanna be she sucked
• ManO'War

  

  I say the asian chick needs to go, she only got there in the first place to fill out their PC lineup.
• se-alum

  

  ManO'War;706074 wrote:I say the asian chick needs to go, she only got there in the first place to fill out their PC lineup.

  Thia?? She's a hell of a singer.
• thavoice

  So mad i missed PIa...ohw did she look last night?
• Tiger2003

  

  thavoice;706113 wrote:So mad i missed PIa...ohw did she look last night?

  
  Amazing!!!
• Tiger2003

  

  rydawg5;706044 wrote:the country singer annoys the crap out me. he smirks or something the whole time and he isnteven that good. he needs to go or the selena wanna be she sucked

  
  Scotty is very good. Even if he doesn't win American Idol someone in Nashville will be calling him. He will be a very good country singer. He did very good last night singing The River by Garth Brooks!!
• thavoice

  Tiger2003;706175 wrote:Amazing!!!

  
  
  dammit!
  
  The country dude annoys me too. If I heard of the radio I guess it would not be as bad, still annoying, but his voice does not match at all how he looks and it is just wierd
• Tiger2003

  

  thavoice;706183 wrote:dammit!
  
  The country dude annoys me too. If I heard of the radio I guess it would not be as bad, still annoying, but his voice does not match at all how he looks and it is just wierd

  
  Well I guess I like it because I am a huge Country Music guy. My fiancé and I both like Josh Turner and that is who his voice reminds you of and Turner voice does not match his look.
• september63

  

  I picked Pia several weeks ago. Also, for those thinking the show would tank after Simon? Ratings are up over 3 million viewers per week from last year!!
• thavoice

  I am no expert but I think the ratings has to do with the talent. I have only watched since I think Sparks girl won it..maybe a year before that..do not rmember..but from to top to bottom it is the best i have ever seen.
  
  I find myself not really caring about the judges and what they say now....but when simon was there I was always interested in what they said. Maybe now people are focuising more on the music and nothing else
• Tiger2003

  

  Steven Tyler is sure not hurting.
• THE4RINGZ

  

  I like what Tyler has added to the show, altough last night he seemed a little off.
• thavoice

  Dont know if anyone mentioned it but last night was not live. It was recorded. ARticle I read it was recorded so the judges can work out their roles and i guess there was sound issues last week.
• se-alum

  

  thavoice;706215 wrote:Dont know if anyone mentioned it but last night was not live. It was recorded. ARticle I read it was recorded so the judges can work out their roles and i guess there was sound issues last week.

  The sound was terrible last week!! Tyler hasn't been very good the last couple shows. I imagine FOX may have him censoring himself quite a bit, which really isn't his style.
• thavoice

  se-alum;706270 wrote:The sound was terrible last week!! Tyler hasn't been very good the last couple shows. I imagine FOX may have him censoring himself quite a bit, which really isn't his style.

  
  Or is he really not that good 'live' in the role of a judge? UP until recently they can pick out what to show but at some point that stops. Kinda like with taht dyke last season....in the recorded eps she sounded ok but when the show came live she stumbled and really showed how little she knew and contributed.
• se-alum

  

  thavoice;706287 wrote:Or is he really not that good 'live' in the role of a judge? UP until recently they can pick out what to show but at some point that stops. Kinda like with taht dyke last season....in the recorded eps she sounded ok but when the show came live she stumbled and really showed how little she knew and contributed.

  Also a possibility, but Steven Tyler doesn't seem like a guy that would be at a loss for words, to me.
• september63

  

  I noticed it wasnt live when he wished that girl a Happy International Womens Day, which was March 8th.
• fish82

  

  Tiger2003;706179 wrote:Scotty is very good. Even if he doesn't win American Idol someone in Nashville will be calling him. He will be a very good country singer. He did very good last night singing The River by Garth Brooks!!

  This. He could get the boot tonight and someone in Nashville will sign him by morning. He's golden no matter where he finishes.
• rydawg5

  fish82;706726 wrote:This. He could get the boot tonight and someone in Nashville will sign him by morning. He's golden no matter where he finishes.

  
  If thats the case I should move to Nashville now. "The River" is a terribly easy song to sing and he did "Okay" -- He is a dime a dozen in nashville with no stage presence.
• bigdaddy2003

  

  I like Scott. I don't think he is amazing but I would rather hear him than Jacob Lusk. I admit the guy has power but there is something about the way he sings that I just don't care for.
• se-alum

  

  bigdaddy2003;706744 wrote:I like Scott. I don't think he is amazing but I would rather hear him than Jacob Lusk. I admit the guy has power but there is something about the way he sings that I just don't care for.

  
  I muted Lusk halfway through his song.
• Tiger2003

  

  rydawg5;706733 wrote:If thats the case I should move to Nashville now. "The River" is a terribly easy song to sing and he did "Okay" -- He is a dime a dozen in nashville with no stage presence.

  
  I would love to hear you sing The River if it is terribly easy. Scotty has been very consistent. He had one performance he didn't perform at his best but other then that he has been a top 4 singer every time.