Would you do this trade?

• DeyDurkie5

  

  Trade Brandon Marshall, Ryan Grant, and Donald Driver for MJD
  
  
  My starting lineup would be...
  
  QB- Peyton Manning
  RB- Michael Turner
  RB- MJD
  Flx- Fred Jackson, Pierre Garcon, Nate Burleson
  WR- Andre Johnson
  WR- Vincent Jackson
  TE-Mercedes Lewis
  Def/Special teams- Atlanta
  K- Mason Crosby
  
  Well, what do you think?
• Laley23

  

  DeyDurkie5;877725 wrote:Trade Brandon Marshall, Ryan Grant, and Donald Driver for MJD
  
  
  My starting lineup would be...
  
  QB- Peyton Manning
  RB- Michael Turner
  RB- MJD
  Flx- Fred Jackson, Pierre Garcon, Nate Burleson
  WR- Andre Johnson
  WR- Vincent Jackson
  TE-Mercedes Lewis
  Def/Special teams- Atlanta
  K- Mason Crosby
  
  Well, what do you think?

  No.
  
  MJD + Jackson/Garcon/whoever in Flex wont be as good as; Grant + Marshall (in the Flex). Which is what the trade would essentially come down to.
• DeyDurkie5

  

  Laley23;877728 wrote:No.
  
  MJD + Jackson/Garcon/whoever in Flex wont be as good as; Grant + Marshall (in the Flex). Which is what the trade would essentially come down to.

  Everything I have read is that Grant will be 2nd back to Starks.
• Laley23

  

  DeyDurkie5;877730 wrote:Everything I have read is that Grant will be 2nd back to Starks.

  Well, I wouldnt put much stock into that. I had Grant a few seasons ago and all I heard was he wouldnt be getting much time and then hed get 20 carries.
  
  Not that it matters a whole lot, I would still think the #2 for GB would put up better numbers than Fred Jackson on a horrendous Buffalo offense.
  
  Im not sold on MJD having a great year either with Jax being terrible and will be forced to throw a lot. Marshal has proven to be a stud no matter the offense or QB throwing to him.